John Jordan, 1871, no party
Corliss Stone, 1872, Republican
John Jordan, 1873, no party
Moses Maddocks, 1873, Republican
John Collins, 1873, Democrat
Henry Yesler, 1874, Republican
Bailey Gatzert, 1875, Independent.
Gideon Weed, 1876, no party
Beriah Brown, 1878, People's Ticket
Orange Jacobs, 1879, Republican
Levi Smith, 1880, Republican
Henry Struve, 1882, Republican
John Leary, 1884, Business Men's Ticket
Henry Yesler, 1885, Republican.
William Shoudy, 1886, People's Party
Thomas T. Minor, 1887, Republican
Robert Moran, 1888, Republican
Harry White, 1890, Republican.
George Hall, 1891, Republican
James Ronald, 1892, Democrat
Byron Phelps, 1894, Republican.
Frank Black, 1896, Republican
W.D. Wood, 1896, Republican
Thomas Humes, 1897, Republican
Richard Ballinger, 1904, Republican
William Hickman Moore, 1906, Democrat
John Miller, 1908, Republican
Hiram Gill, 1910, Republican
(Nonpartisan elections were established in the 1910 city charter.)
George Dilling, 1911
George Cotterill, 1912
Hiram Gill, 1914
Ole Hanson, 1918
C.B. Fitzgerald, 1919
Hugh Caldwell, 1920
Edwin Brown, 1922
Bertha Landes, 1926
Frank Edwards, 1928
Robert Harlin, 1931
John Dore, 1932
Charles Smith, 1934
John Dore, 1936
Arthur Langlie, 1938
John Carroll, 1941
Earl Millikin, 1941
William Devin, 1942
Allan Pomeroy, 1952
Gordon Clinton, 1956
J.D. "Dorm" Braman, 1964
Floyd Miller, 1969
Wes Uhlman, 1969
Charles Royer, 1978
Norm Rice, 1990
Paul Schell, 1998